Soundfish vs [untitled]

What both do

Both keep notes pinned to a moment in a track, and both play a new take at a link you already shared. Music Ally reports that collaborators on [untitled] leave notes on specific parts of a track by timestamp, that replaced audio reaches links shared earlier, and that you can switch back to compare versions.

On Soundfish, listeners comment at a moment on the waveform, a new take plays at the same link, and each track keeps up to 25 dated revisions.

Where [untitled] is the better choice

• You want a workspace for drafts. Music Ally describes projects and folders synced across iPhone and the web, with recording in the app and an offline mode for listening, editing, and organizing.
• You want to edit in the same place: Music Ally lists trimming, varispeed, EQ, and stem splitting.
• You want to control who hears a draft and get a notification when someone listens.
• You want to sell a project to fans. Music Ally reports that Paid Projects sells in the app with no platform cut, and that vinyl pressing can be ordered there too.

Where Soundfish is the better choice

• No app or membership: a Soundfish album page opens in any browser, with comments, hearts, and the embed included.
• The player embeds on any site. Copy the code from the album’s manage page, or run soundfish audio embed <album> --html.
• The soundfish CLI publishes albums from a terminal, and every album page has a Markdown version an agent can read. The agent guide covers both.

What each costs

The [untitled] iPhone app is free, and its App Store listing sells a membership at $7.99 a month or $49.99 a year. Music Ally reports the same prices.

Soundfish costs $0. A free Hraness account publishes one album of up to 10 tracks, each an MP3, WAV, or FLAC file up to 200 MiB. The pricing page lists every limit.

See also

• All comparisons